The
'Science' of Star Wars
Today’s science fiction is tomorrow’s reality. Or is it? History has
taught us that it is never wise to claim that certain technologies are
impossible. In previous generations, scientists have told James Watt, Thomas
Edison and the Wright brothers that the steam engine, the light bulb and
the airplane were impossible; and they have lived through these inventions
and watched them change the world. However, without making claims of impossibility,
we can say that there are certain futuristic technologies that appear very
unlikely given our current understanding of the laws of nature. And as
it turns out, many of the technologies depicted in the Star Wars trilogy
fit into this category.
Light
Sabers
Light sabers are one such technology. These are unique to the Star
Wars trilogy and, in essence, are blades of pure energy capable of cutting
through virtually anything. Curiously, the Star Wars homepage has provided
a detailed explanation of how these devices work, however, it is entirely
fictitious. In an attempt to rectify this situation, scientists have arduously
speculated over how such a weapon could be constructed. However,
it appears that the force is not with the laser physicists of our galaxy,
and they have been unsuccessful in their searches.
The main problem is that a light saber cannot simply exist as a focused
laser beam, interference pattern or evanescent wave; because these beams
would pass straight through each other in a duel (light beams don’t repel
each other). The alternative is to construct an intense electromagnetic
field with one of these devices, and fire high-energy photons into its
interior. The photons would be reflected off the sides of the field and
hence be contained within it, therefore creating the glowing and humming
effects of a light saber. But the problems arise when we consider the stability,
versatility and power requirements of such a model. The energy dissipated
in the electromagnetic field when the saber is disabled would be sufficient
to annihilate its user, its low stability making it more of a self-destructive
weapon than an offensive one.
So until someone discovers a new law of physics, it looks like we will
have to settle for those retina burning laser pointers and plastic imitation
light sabers, which will no doubt be in abundance over the next few months.
Ray
Guns
Today we can construct laser beams that are powerful enough to blast
through steel. The only restriction on the power that we can pack into
a laser beam is the stability of the lasing material and the energy source
that we use to drive the laser. The main problem with creating the ray
guns depicted in Star Wars, is that in order to blast the amount of power
of a nuclear power plant out of one of these ray guns, the gun must first
be connected to a nuclear power plant (and I didn’t see too many nuclear
power plants attached to ray guns in the Star Wars trilogy). A portable
power pack for a ray gun does not currently exist, and scientists don’t
even know where to start looking.
It appears that George Lucas didn’t know either, when he made Star Wars.
If you look closely at a ray gun or blaster whenever it is fired, you can
actually see it ejecting spent shells. In the scene where Luke and Leia
make their tarzan-like swing on the Death Star, you can actually see these
shells hit the floor and roll around. This is because Lucasfilms actually
modified ordinary guns to make their blasters, and loaded them with blanks
so that they would recoil.
The
American Star Wars Program
The problem of portable nuclear power plants was also faced by actor
and US President, Ronald Reagan, when he proposed the American Star Wars
program in 1983. The original scheme was to place thousands of hydrogen
bombs in a number of X-ray lasers orbiting Earth in small satellites. When
a bomb was detonated, its burst of X-rays would be diverted along copper
rods to generate intense X-ray laser beams capable of shooting down thousands
of Russian warheads in a very short period of time. However, calculations
after the proposal revealed that even these bomb-driven X-ray lasers would
not have the energy required to execute these attacks.
But despite the dismissal of the Star Wars program by many American
scientists, Gorbachev took the threat seriously, and the program has actually
been credited as one of the contributing factors involved in the eventual
breakup of the Soviet Union (or the “evil empire” as Reagan called it).
Research into the Star Wars program is still going ahead, however it
has adopted the less assuming role of defense for the time being. In 1990,
Boeing was awarded a contract with the US Government to design and develop
ETVs (or Exoatmospheric kinetic Kill Vehicles). But don’t be fooled by
the name (which is probably intentional) - these vehicles are actually
part of the National Missile Defense system. When a foreign missile is
detected, they are launched, attached to Ground-Based Interceptors. Then,
in space, they separate from their Ground-Based Interceptors, detect target
missiles and destroy them by interception.
Force
Fields
These transparent, impenetrable walls of pure energy portrayed in the
Star Wars trilogy would surely be a desirable addition to America’s National
Missile Defense system. But before we consider how we might construct such
a field, we find that our current knowledge of physics doesn’t even allow
us to construct one.
We can’t use electromagnetic fields as force fields, because electromagnetically
neutral objects (such as plastics) would travel straight through them without
being deflected. We can’t use gravitational fields because they are attractive
rather than repulsive, and they are extremely weak. And we can’t use the
weak and strong nuclear forces either, because they act over atomic and
subatomic distances (in contrast to the force fields in Star Wars which
act over kilometers).
With no other forces to choose from, there is nothing we know of that
could give rise to these force fields. So if we really want to protect
ourselves against potentially irritating surprise plastic raids from space
in the near future, then our only hope lies in the opinions of nuclear
physicists, who generally agree that our current quantum theory is incomplete.
And so there is a small possibility that future developments in this branch
of physics might one day make these elusive structures possible.
The
Unified Theory of Star Wars
But maybe we are looking for answers in all the wrong places (or the
wrong Universes). There is a group of Internet Star Wars fans who believe
that this is the case, and that they have found the answer to all of the
apparent inconsistencies that I have mentioned. Unsatisfied with the restrictive
and constraining physical laws that our Universe seems to have imposed
upon us, they have invested their spare time laboriously reinventing the
laws of physics so that these laws may be consistent with Star Wars phenomena
and technology in another Universe. In order to formulate their equations,
they have utilized any information they have been able to extract or deduce
from the movie series, including:
-
Physical and orbital characteristics of the filmed celestial bodies
-
The dimensions, structure and capabilities of the Death Star
-
Physical speculations into superluminal travel as depicted in the movie
series
-
The speed of rays emitted from ray blasters (which is surprisingly lower
the speed of light)
But I wonder whether they have considered if their new laws of physics
are consistent with the evolution of life and it’s remarkable resemblance
our own here on Earth. Personally, I don’t think that convergent evolution
would have occurred to such a degree under such differing physical conditions…
but maybe that’s looking into it just a little too far!
|